Do you still remember Newt Gingrich’s Conservative Revolution of 1994? Back then, the Republicans defeated Clinton’s Democrats by an even wider margin than the one by which Republicans have just lost. There was talk of a fundamental transformation of America. And what actually happened? Nothing of the sort. Clinton served out his presidency, accomplished everything he needed to accomplish, and is remembered as a highly successful president. The Republicans who controlled Congress spent the rest of their time making futile attempts to remove him from office and endlessly dwelling on his sex scandal. In doing so, they alienated enough voters to lose a substantial share of their newly won seats in subsequent elections.

Oskar Krejčí published an interesting article yesterday. I would particularly draw your attention to the table showing how many congressional seats the president’s party lost in various election years. Trump’s results are dismal, but they are by no means exceptionally dismal. It is only in newspaper commentaries and entertainment podcasts that every minor development is portrayed as a fundamental turning point in world history.

But let us return to what I wrote two years ago, following Trump’s presidential victory.

  • Events should not be explained in terms of individual details that are essentially accidental. A better approach is to examine how major systemic transformations unfolded in European history and what general patterns can be derived from them. This allows for a deeper understanding and more reliable predictions.

  • Those who lead revolutions are almost never the ones who govern afterward. Who in 1789 could have imagined Napoleon? And who in 1917 could have envisioned the Stalinist bureaucracy?

  • The pre-revolutionary regime never returns, even when the revolution itself is defeated.

Image (image)

All of this still holds true. Now imagine what might have happened if Trotsky had departed after just a few months and the Bolsheviks had been unable to win the Civil War without him. Most likely, Russia would have entered a prolonged period of chaos and violence. Some local warlord might have seized power, or Russia might have fragmented into a patchwork of petty kingdoms. And Russia would certainly have become an attractive target for various foreign powers. Who would not have wanted to carve out a piece for themselves? Perhaps a new unifier would eventually have emerged, most likely an extraordinarily brutal and militarily capable one. Or perhaps no such figure would have appeared at all.

This is one way of understanding the United States today. It is extremely unlikely that the country will break apart. But it is by no means impossible that, within the next generation, the Muslim Brotherhood or some drug cartel will establish an enclave of its own on American territory. Regardless of whether that happens, violence, impoverishment, and the slide into backwardness will continue, along with the ongoing replacement of the population and ever-accelerating Islamization. Ten years ago, almost nobody was aware of the political ambitions of the Muslim community in the United States. Today, that community is one of the key players in the struggle for power. The speed of Islamization is astonishing.

Why has Trump been so unsuccessful in economic policy, even compared with his first term? There are probably many reasons, but one of them is likely that American society and the economy are in far worse condition than they were eight years ago. The notion that removing a few of the worst regulations, perhaps combined with restraining foreign competition, would be enough to make everything flourish has proved to be a naive illusion.

What is needed is a much more profound transformation—one that will not happen spontaneously and that the market itself cannot bring about. The last time America experienced a transformation of this magnitude was under Franklin Delano Roosevelt, almost a century ago.

Leave a Reply