Another insight from my discussion with a young mathematician, one that has become particularly relevant in light of recent events. If political activists find emotional fulfillment in their activism, then surely the primary issue is not ideology but emotion. Any particular emotion (in effect, a flow of neurotransmitters) can be triggered by entirely different ideologies. The emotional experience of someone fighting to save the country from Babiš is, in terms of what happens in the brain, identical to that of someone fighting to save the country from Soros. It should therefore be possible to redirect these people toward something else and give them the same satisfaction through activities that are far less harmful.
I should add that the feeling of “saving the world from evil” is much more satisfying when money and political power come with it. If not for oneself, then perhaps for one’s children, friends, and so on. Nevertheless, with this one qualification, the observation is correct.
After all, this is precisely what Curtis Yarvin has in mind when he speaks of “seducing” liberal activists. He means offering them a different ideology and a different organizational structure that would satisfy their needs even better. Or at least the needs of some of them. For example, those who are losing out in the internal struggle for influence, prestige, and resources. Why not give Tomáš Sedláček a call and offer him a prestigious position with the Motorists?
More generally, however, I must emphasize that this way of thinking and understanding the world applies not only to individuals but to entire groups. It is not simply a matter of seducing individuals.
But that is only a small part of the larger issue. Let us consider a hypothetical future situation in which the liberal regime collapses completely. It might be replaced overnight by some future regime, or the transition might take place gradually, so slowly that we scarcely notice it happening. Such gradual transitions are more common in history.
And here I return once again to Curtis Yarvin. A regime change is complete when all the important officials and activists of the overthrown regime have found a place in the new order and are satisfied with their positions.
Unless we intend to resort to mass executions, gouging out eyes, and castrations, we must recognize a simple fact: a new regime can afford to have hundreds of discontented people, but it cannot afford hundreds of thousands. That would be destabilizing.
This is why most revolutionary regimes follow a familiar pattern. First, they demonstrate their determination, sometimes even through exemplary acts of cruelty. But then they offer the frightened people something reasonably satisfactory.
