That is how the matter is expressed in Utley’s Essay on Conservatism, and the formulation is perfect. We could hear exactly the same thing from Roman Joch. Or, for that matter, from Roger Scruton.

It is a vision of the world in which there is nothing good in human beings, and the only question is how to prevent these terrifying creatures from doing even greater harm. Control and restrain, restrain and control. The moment we loosen our grip, human nature will break free of its chains and destroy the world.

Indeed, this is precisely what I once described as the first conservative dogma: “Every human being is inherently and irredeemably corrupt.”

But isn’t religion supposed to be, above all, a source of joy and vitality? Isn’t social tradition supposed to be a welcome and pleasant guide? And isn’t it true that the overwhelming majority of us rarely find ourselves in situations where only the threat of criminal punishment prevents us from doing wrong?

But let us return to the conservative view of human nature. Notice how closely it resembles the attitude of fanatical liberals. They, too, see a world filled with dangerous tendencies: sexism, patriarchy, the destruction of the planet, and so on. They feel compelled to impose ever tighter controls on people in order to save the world from these evils. Their demands grow increasingly severe, yet nothing ever seems sufficient. Each camp calls its own system of control “freedom” and the rival system “oppression.”

Still, the two are not entirely identical. Conservative strictness produces a world that may be dull and joyless, but in which stable life remains possible. Liberal strictness produces a society that is unbearable and extremely unstable.

I should also point out that alongside this fundamental, dogmatic conservatism, there is another, more ordinary and natural kind of conservatism, which amounts to little more than skepticism toward progressive excesses.

And what does the latest generation of experimental social psychology have to say about all this?

It tells us that the overwhelming majority of us possess both a tendency to act well and a tendency to act badly. We are capable of selfishness, but also of sacrificing ourselves for others. The challenge is to find a reasonable balance between freedom, control, and positive encouragement.

Extremes are destructive. Abolishing the police is one extreme; imposing excessive strictness on everyone is another. The latter always carries the risk of bringing out the worst in the personality of those exercising control—or in those who control the controllers, or those who control the controllers of the controllers, and so on.

Moreover, we are facing a conflict with Islam, whose fundamental and central idea, as well as its underlying impulse, is to compel everyone—including Muslims themselves—to obey sacred scriptures blindly and abandon the pursuit of personal happiness.

We cannot win that conflict by offering a watered-down version of Islam. We can win only by setting something fundamentally different against it.

Leave a Reply